When night falls in Tampa, and the air hums with the buzz of traffic and chatter, one craving seems to echo louder than most—pizza. And not just any pizza. We’re talking about hand-tossed, sauce-swirled, cheese-blanketed masterpieces straight from the ovens of Tampa’s finest. We asked our nearly 400,000 Instagram followers to reveal their go-to pizza joints. The response? Overwhelming. What followed was a flood of recommendations pointing us toward slices that tell stories—of New York streets, Jersey roots, and Roman romance.
Here are the 11 best pizza spots in Tampa, each a local favorite, each one worth every single bite. Bookmark this guide, follow the aroma, and prepare to be obsessed.
1. Santoro’s Pizzeria
📍 1329 W Cass St | Website
Step through the door, and you’re in New Jersey—or at least your taste buds are. Owner Travis Kaiser grew up surrounded by Jersey-style pizza, and Santoro’s is his homage to that heritage. Crispy crusts, fresh toppings, and classic techniques converge here. Each bite is loud with authenticity—no gimmicks, just solid, soul-satisfying pizza.
Instagram: @santorospizzeria
2. Colony Grill
📍 3640 Midtown Dr | Website
You don’t find many places like Colony Grill. Originally from Connecticut, this place has mastered the art of the thin bar pie. But it’s the hot oil topping—a spicy, slick kiss of flavor—that makes each pie unforgettable. Their Tampa location in Midtown is not just popular; it’s the official pizza partner of the Tampa Bay Rays. That’s right—this pie has fans in the dugout.
Instagram: @colonygrill
3. Cappy’s Pizza
📍 4910 N Florida Ave | Website
You know you’ve found a gem when a place lets you choose between Chicago deep dish and New York thin crust under one roof. Since 1995, Cappy’s has anchored the Seminole Heights community, serving up family vibes with every pie. Don’t miss their vegan options either—because pizza should be for everyone.
Instagram: @cappyspizza
4. Due Amici
📍 1724 E 7th Ave | Website
Located in the cobblestone heart of Ybor City, Due Amici is the sort of place that smells like home. It’s a family-owned pizza bar, and you’ll taste that love in every house-made dough, every spoon of handcrafted sauce. Pair a pizza with pasta and a local craft beer—and don’t plan to move for a while.
Instagram: @dueamiciybor
5. New York New York Pizza
📍 533 S Howard Ave & 1512 E 7th Ave | Website
Oversized slices, gooey cheese, and that unmistakable fold—New York New York Pizza brings Big Apple energy to Tampa. It’s loud, bold, and especially lively after dark. Whether you’re stumbling in post-club or fueling up pre-party, this place delivers the real NYC deal.
Instagram: @nynypizzatampa
6. Eddie & Sam’s NY Pizza
📍 203 E Twiggs St | Website
Here’s a twist worthy of a movie plot: Eddie & Sam’s imports actual NYC water to make their dough. Yes, really. The result? Pizza so authentic, you’d swear you’re in Queens. Don’t skip the Lasagna Pie—with ricotta, marinara, ground beef, and mozzarella, it’s a slice that demands your full attention.
Instagram: @eddieandsamspizza
7. 3 Corners Pizza
📍 813 Water St | Website
Located across from Amalie Arena, 3 Corners Pizza serves up hand-tossed slices and whole pies with a sports-bar twist. Watch the game, grab a cold beer, and enjoy downtown’s go-to pre-game stop. It’s fast, flavorful, and infused with community energy.
Instagram: @3cornerspizza
8. Doormet
📍 1155 S Dale Mabry Hwy #12 | Website
Gourmet without the snobbery—Doormet offers high-quality ingredients, health-conscious options, and killer pizza whether you’re dining in or ordering out. Think upscale taste with neighborhood comfort. A hidden gem perfect for your next cozy night in.
Instagram: @doormet
9. Fabrica Pizza
📍 142 S Meridian Ave | Website
Neapolitan pizza done fast and done right. Fabrica is sleek, modern, and Italian-inspired to its core. Their Verdura pizza, topped with broccolini, whipped ricotta, and chili flakes, is art on a crust. A must-visit for lovers of light, blistered dough and curated toppings.
Instagram: @fabricapizza
10. Forbici Modern Italian
📍 1633 W Snow Ave | Website
If you’re looking for pizza with a side of style, Forbici is your spot. Located in Hyde Park Village, this upscale eatery serves Roman-style crusts paired with curated toppings, Italian tapas, and wines on tap. It’s sophisticated yet casual—a place to linger.
Instagram: @eatforbici
11. Lee’s Grocery
📍 2210 N Central Ave | Website
The name might suggest a convenience store—but Lee’s Grocery is anything but. It’s a craft beer bar, neighborhood hangout, and stone-baked pizza haven all in one. Pool tables, vegan options, and a welcoming patio make this the hidden treasure of Tampa’s pizza world.
Instagram: @leesgrocery
Support Local. Eat Loud. Share the Slice.
These 11 spots represent the beating heart of Tampa’s pizza scene, but they’re just the beginning. Did we miss your favorite? Tag us on Instagram, send a DM, or shout out your go-to joint in the comments. Let’s keep Tampa’s oven burning hot with love for local pizza legends.
The city is alive with crust, sauce, and stories. You just have to take a bite.
Are you on social media? Check out our profile for more local news! Follow @TampaLatest for up-to-the-minute updates in Tampa, Florida.