Thanksgiving season in Tampa wouldn’t be complete without a hunt for the best Thanksgiving pies Tampa has to offer. From century-old bakeries to modern artisanal shops, the city is bursting with fresh-baked goodness, seasonal flavors, and handcrafted treats that turn any feast into a celebration. With so many delicious options across town, this guide helps you discover the perfect pie—whether it’s for your entire family, a laid-back friendsgiving, or simply your own cozy Netflix night.
Visit each bakery’s official site, explore their social media, and order ahead before these holiday favorites sell out fast.
Why Tampa Is a Pie-Lover’s Paradise
Thanksgiving is all about tradition, togetherness, and comfort, and Tampa brings all of that to life through its rich baking culture. Whether you’re craving fruity classics, silky custards, or decadent nuts and chocolate, the city’s bakeries offer high-quality pies, local craftsmanship, and incredible flavor. Grab your fork… because these treats are worth every bite.
Top Places in Tampa for Thanksgiving Pies
Alessi Bakery – 2909 W Cypress St
Official Site: https://www.alessibakery.com
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/alessibakery
For more than a century, Alessi Bakery has built a reputation for timeless recipes, scratch-made desserts, and beloved holiday pies. Their menu is the stuff of Thanksgiving dreams, offering classic flavors that Tampa families have trusted for generations. Whether you want traditional fruit pies or something rich and creamy, Alessi always delivers perfection.
Boulon Brasserie & Bakery – 1001 Water Street
Official Site: https://www.boulontampa.com
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/boulonbrasserie
Boulon is the chic French-inspired showstopper of Water Street, crafting elegant pies such as the Apple and Brown Butter Tart, Hummingbird Pecan Tart, and Brûlée Buttermilk Vanilla Bean Pie. Each dessert blends sophisticated flavor, artistry, and top-quality ingredients, making them some of the most luxurious holiday pies in Tampa.
Chocolate Pi – 5207 N Florida Ave
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/chocolatepi_tampa
Chocolate Pi is known for creative baking, seasonal specialties, and handcrafted sweets that locals adore. This Thanksgiving, they’re offering Old-fashioned apple pi, Southern Pecan pi, and Chocolate pecan pi. Every slice is beautifully made, visually stunning, and ridiculously delicious.
HaleLife Bakery – 1155 South Dale Mabry Hwy
Official Site: https://www.halelifebakery.com
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/halelifebakery
HaleLife brings gluten-free, vegan, and allergen-friendly baking to a whole new level. Their holiday lineup includes Pumpkin Pie, Apple Crumble Pie, and Peach Cobbler. Each treat is crafted with care so everyone can enjoy Thanksgiving dessert without missing out on flavor.
Mike’s Pies – 10350 Windhorst Rd
Official Site: https://www.mikespies.com
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/mikespies
Mike’s Pies is a Tampa institution—and as the name suggests, they take pie-making, quality, and tradition extremely seriously. With half a dozen rotating options, they deliver some of Tampa’s most iconic Thanksgiving flavors. Place your orders early, as these popular pies sell out fast.
The Pearl – 823 Water Street
Official Site: https://www.thepearlrestaurant.com
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/thepearlwaterstreet
The Pearl may be known for oysters and comfort food, but don’t overlook their Brown Sugar Pie, a seasonal favorite with rich flavor. With gluten-free options, house-made crust, and daily availability, it’s the perfect pick for anyone who loves warm, caramel-like sweetness.
State Flower Bakery – 5224 S Dale Mabry Hwy
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/stateflowerbakery
State Flower Bakery offers scratch-made pies, simple ingredients, and homemade charm year-round. Their Thanksgiving pies often sell out due to unbeatable flavor and craftsmanship. Pre-order early if you want a guaranteed slice of heaven this holiday season.
Sucre Table – 4048 W Kennedy Blvd
Official Site: https://www.sucretable.com
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/sucretable
Sucre Table is known for culinary artistry, modern desserts, and incredible seasonal pies. This year, their lineup includes Caramel Apple, Pumpkin, Bourbon Pecan, Red Wine Poached Pear Cheesecake, and Blueberry Lemon Tart. Each creation is crafted with stunning flavor combinations and beautiful presentation.
Wright’s Gourmet House – 1200 S Dale Mabry Hwy
Official Site: https://www.wrightsgourmet.com
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/wrightsgourmethouse
Wright’s offers a delightful mix of holiday favorites, fresh-baked pies, and seasonal treats. Enjoy their Pumpkin Pie, the Pumpkin Raisin Nut Gingerbread Loaf, or try one of their signature quiches—because yes, savory pies count too! Their dedication to flavor and texture makes this a top pick every year.
Have a Place to Add?
If you know a bakery or café serving unforgettable Tampa pies, email info@thatssotampa.com—sharing amazing local finds makes the holiday season even sweeter.
Ready for More Tampa Food Adventures? If you loved discovering Tampa’s best pies, stay tuned—there’s a whole world of local restaurants, seasonal flavors, and hidden gems waiting to be explored next.
Are you on social media? Check out our profile for more local news! Follow @TampaLatest for up-to-the-minute updates in Tampa, Florida.