Sometimes, nothing hits like a late-night pizza slice after a concert, a long day, or a few drinks with friends. Whether you crave a classic margherita, a gooey stuffed slice, or a fiery Buffalo chicken masterpiece, these Tampa Bay pizzerias have you covered. Bookmark this list for those moments when the craving hits—and thank us later.
1. Due Amici Pizza & Pasta
Craving a midnight slice? “Due Amici Pizza & Pasta” in Ybor City is the go-to spot for night owls. You can stroll right up to their glowing glass case and grab a slice of cheesy heaven until 3 a.m. Whether you’re into stuffed crusts or creative toppings, this Tampa staple guarantees satisfaction.
👉 Visit their official site: dueamicipizza.com
📱 Follow them on Instagram: @dueamiciybor
2. Santoro’s
When a pizza joint earns a 7.8 rating from Barstool Sports’ Dave Portnoy, you know it’s legit. “Santoro’s” in North Hyde Park wins over locals with its unbeatable $7 lunch deal—one plain slice, one specialty slice, and a drink. It’s the perfect lunch break indulgence without breaking the bank.
👉 Official site: santorospizza.com
📱 Follow them on Instagram: @santorospizzatampa
3. Joey Brooklyn’s
Ask any St. Pete local where to get a late-night slice, and they’ll point you to “Joey Brooklyn’s.” Located just steps from Jannus Live, this pizzeria is a post-concert legend. The slices are massive, the toppings endless, and the vibe pure Florida cool. Grab one after a show and taste why it’s a downtown favorite.
👉 Official site: joeybrooklynspizza.com
📱 Follow them on Instagram: @joeybrooklynspizza
4. Eddie and Sam’s NY Pizza
“Eddie and Sam’s NY Pizza” is downtown Tampa’s crown jewel for authentic New York-style pizza. Their slices are enormous—no, really, gargantuan—and their variety is unmatched, from pepperoni perfection to spicy Buffalo chicken. With their imported New York water, every bite tastes like the Big Apple itself.
👉 Official site: eddieandsamspizza.com
📱 Follow them on Instagram: @eddieandsamsnypizza
5. Toby’s Original Little Italy Pizza
Don’t be fooled by the strip mall exterior—“Toby’s Original Little Italy Pizza” in St. Pete is an old-school gem. Inside, you’ll find red booths, arcade games, and that unmistakable New York pizzeria energy. Try a classic cheese slice for under $5 and toss in some garlic knots for the perfect finishing touch.
👉 Official site: tobysoriginalpizza.com
📱 Follow them on Instagram: @tobysoriginalpizza
6. Forbici
Forbici Modern Italian in Hyde Park Village brings sophistication to your pizza cravings. Their square-shaped margherita and Cup & Char pizza are slice perfection—crispy, cheesy, and perfect with a happy hour cocktail. This spot redefines what a pizza night can feel like.
👉 Official site: eatforbici.com
📱 Follow them on Instagram: @eatforbici
7. Heights Pizza
While technically not a “slice joint,” “Heights Pizza” earns its place with its two-slice combo deals that include a drink. The crust is crispy, the sauce robust, and the vibe effortlessly cool and casual—ideal for a quick stop between errands or a relaxed hangout in Tampa Heights.
👉 Official site: heightspizza.com
📱 Follow them on Instagram: @heightspizza
Late-Night Pizza Heaven in Tampa Bay
Whether you’re out late in Ybor, catching a show in St. Pete, or exploring Hyde Park, these pizza spots deliver unforgettable flavor and energy. From authentic New York slices to local craft creations, Tampa Bay’s pizza scene is a testament to the city’s late-night spirit.
So next time that craving hits, you know where to go. Just make sure to grab extra napkins—and maybe a friend to share (or not).
Which of these Tampa Bay pizza slice spots will you hit first? Or better yet—why not make it a pizza crawl and taste them all in one night?
Are you on social media? Check out our profile for more local news! Follow @TampaLatest for up-to-the-minute updates in Tampa, Florida.