Caretta on the Gulf, located inside the luxurious Sandpearl Resort at 500 Mandalay Avenue, has officially earned national recognition as one of America’s “Best Fine Dining Restaurants”, according to TripAdvisor’s Travelers’ Choice Awards. This prestigious honor cements Caretta’s place among the top restaurants in Clearwater, known for its blend of refined coastal cuisine and breathtaking Gulf views.
Upscale Dining in Clearwater with a 5-Star View
Named after the loggerhead sea turtles that nest along Florida’s shores, Caretta on the Gulf delivers a coastal dining experience that captures Clearwater’s natural beauty. Guests can savor sunset views, handcrafted cocktails, and wines from the restaurant’s organic wine list, all while overlooking the sparkling waters of the Gulf of Mexico.
Every dish celebrates fresh, seasonal ingredients—from locally caught seafood to hand-selected produce—crafted with artistry and precision. The restaurant also offers a dedicated organic menu with thoughtfully chosen wine pairings by in-house sommeliers, ensuring an unforgettable fine dining experience.
To make the evening even more seamless, valet parking is included, allowing guests to simply relax and enjoy their evening by the beach—perfect for a romantic date night in Clearwater.
Savor Surf and Turf at Caretta on the Gulf
One of the most talked-about menu highlights is surf and turf—a perfect pairing of tender steak and freshly caught fish, beautifully plated with seasonal vegetables. This dish epitomizes the restaurant’s commitment to culinary excellence, blending flavor, texture, and presentation into one sophisticated meal.
From the first bite, diners can taste the passion for local ingredients and the attention to detail that define every dish at Caretta. Whether you’re indulging in a perfectly seared sea bass or savoring a slice of Key Lime Pie with house-made graham cracker ice cream, every flavor feels meticulously balanced.
The Most Popular Eats at Caretta on the Gulf
According to recent TripAdvisor reviews, Caretta continues to impress guests with its exceptional service, elevated cuisine, and mesmerizing atmosphere. Many diners describe it as a destination-worthy restaurant—ideal for anniversaries, birthdays, or an elegant night out by the water.
Here are some of the most raved-about dishes:
- Clam Chowder – Rich, creamy, and beautifully presented.
- Sea Bass, Salmon, Grouper, and Pork Chop – Cooked to perfection, each with distinctive flavor profiles.
- Watermelon and Beet Salads – A refreshing and vibrant starter.
- Crab Cake – Described by one diner as “dream-worthy.”
- Key Lime Pie – Served with house-made graham cracker ice cream, an absolute must-try.
Guests also love the live music and the calm coastal setting, which make Caretta one of the best date night restaurants in Clearwater. The restaurant’s staff is often praised for being knowledgeable, attentive, and genuinely welcoming, enhancing every guest’s experience.
A Top-Tier Date Night Spot in Pinellas County
Between its award-winning cuisine, oceanfront ambiance, and impeccable service, Caretta on the Gulf has become a beacon of fine dining in Clearwater. Its reputation continues to rise, joining other top local eateries like Clearwater’s own under-the-radar taco spot, recently featured on Yelp’s Top 100 Taco Shops list.
For food enthusiasts and travelers alike, Caretta offers more than just a meal—it’s a culinary journey by the sea. Whether you’re visiting for the first time or returning for another unforgettable evening, it’s clear why Caretta on the Gulf stands among the best fine dining restaurants in America.
See the full Best of the Best Restaurants list by TripAdvisor here.
Ready to Experience Clearwater’s Best Fine Dining?
From ocean views to organic wines, Caretta on the Gulf proves that fine dining and coastal charm can coexist perfectly. Whether it’s your next romantic night out, special celebration, or simply a chance to enjoy life by the water—this Clearwater gem deserves a spot on your list.
Because here, every meal feels like a celebration of the Gulf itself.
Are you on social media? Check out our profile for more local news! Follow @TampaLatest for up-to-the-minute updates in Tampa, Florida.
