TAMPA, Fla. – Tampa City Council members are now considering the possible dissolution of community oversight for the police department, citing a new state law that restricts such boards. The Citizen’s Review Board (CRB) – a panel of 11 dedicated volunteers tasked with examining disciplinary cases and issues involving law enforcement – is now at risk of being disbanded.
Council Members Voice Concerns Over New Legislation
During the discussion, several council members expressed concern about the necessity to act on the state-mandated change.
“No one on the city council wanted to do this — it was brought up by somebody in Tallahassee, am I correct? That ruled these boards not acceptable to the laws of the state of FL?” asked Councilmember Charlie Miranda, confirming with the city attorney, who agreed.
Governor Ron DeSantis recently signed a law limiting civilian oversight, and the council members acknowledged that this legislation leaves them with little choice. “This is not a City of Tampa issue, it’s a Tallahassee issue that we need to conform with,” stated Councilmember Alan Clendenin, expressing his reluctant support for the measure based on legal counsel.
Why the Citizen’s Review Board Was Created
The CRB was established nearly a decade ago as a community response to concerns about policing practices and administrative policies. Council member Bill Carlson reminded his colleagues of the board’s purpose: “The CRB was not meant to police the police. It was created to address an administration that enacted racist policies. We should not have policies that discriminate based on race.” Carlson also voiced support for law enforcement while advocating for equal treatment of all citizens.
Community Voices Express the Need for Transparency
The CRB has long sparked both support and debate among Tampa residents. In 2021, local civil rights groups raised questions about the board’s appointment process, calling for greater transparency and accountability from the Tampa Police Department.
“It is time for accountability… It is time for transparency with the Tampa Police Department,” said Yvette Lewis, NAACP president, highlighting the community’s desire to rebuild trust.
Mayor and CRB Founders Emphasize the Importance of Oversight
Responding to criticism, Mayor Jane Castor supported the transparency efforts of the police, stating, “The Tampa Police Department is a wide-open book… They want as much oversight as possible, and they have invited everyone in.”
One of the CRB’s original founders, Dr. Carolyn Collins, expressed deep concern about the potential dissolution of the board. “I would be very displeased if the city dissolves it completely,” said Collins, stressing the board’s value to the community. She further voiced concern over diminishing support from state legislators, especially in light of upcoming changes in national leadership.
What’s Next for the CRB?
With the recent motion carrying a 5-2 vote, a second reading and final vote on the matter is scheduled for December 5. The Tampa community awaits the council’s decision on the future of this critical platform for police oversight.
WFLA initially published the story. Are you on social media? Check out our profile for more local news! Follow @TampaLatest for up-to-the-minute updates in Tampa, Florida.
